Chapter 61 Vitreoretinal Dystrophies HERMANN D. SCHUBERT and WILLIAM TASMAN Table Of Contents |
Vitreoretinal dystrophies may present on routine ophthalmologic examination
as high myopia, strabismus, retinal detachment, vitreous hemorrhage, or
abnormal fundus pigmentation. The ocular findings are either isolated1–4 or part of a syndrome such as Robin's syndrome (also known as the
Pierre Robin syndrome),5 one of the clefting syndromes,6 or skeletal dysplasia.7 Although the “gestalt” of retinoschisis,1 familial exudative retinopathy (FEVR),2 or original Wagner's disease4 emerges with ease, lengthy deliberation is needed for conceptual separation
of some of the syndromes that are not restricted to the eye.7–12 Whereas identification of specific genes is rapidly emerging,13–22 it is not always clear which of the polymorphous signs to include at this
mostly descriptive stage of nosology, with subsets and syndromes based
on somewhat arbitrary definitions. An ocular dystrophy is a congenital bilateral degeneration of ocular tissues, here predominantly involving the vitreous and retina; the degeneration may be either stationary or progressive. Dystrophic vitreal changes involve liquefaction (synchysis) of the gel and collapse (syneresis) of the collagenous structure. Thus, destruction of the vitreous gel is superimposed on the aging process.12,23 Microscopically, the liquefied vitreous appears optically empty; collapse of the vitreous collagen causes it to appear veil-like. Vitreoretinal adhesions may be absent or abnormally firm. Dystrophic retinal changes include intraretinal splitting, atrophy, hole formation, and migration of pigment from the pigment epithelium. In addition, extraretinal changes sometimes occur. These changes present as selective atrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium, which appears as choroidal tesselation. Independent of this, choroidal stromal atrophy has been described.8 Vitreoretinal dystrophies are found with greater ease by the prepared examiner. It is the purpose of this review to present the basic pathology, as well as the genetic and clinical features, of nine vitreoretinopathies in which primary retinal involvement is accompanied by passive secondary vitreal changes. The habit of thinking of vitreoretinal dystrophies, especially in children, may lead to earlier recognition of patients at risk for retinal detachment and consequent visual loss. |
X-LINKED HEREDITARY RETINOSCHISIS | |||
Although both peripheral and macular retinoschisis were first described
in 1898,24 the other vitreoretinal dystrophies have been described only more recently. The
history of the recognition and naming of the retinoschisis is
particularly interesting, mirroring the progressive characterization
of the lesion, and thus may be helpful in understanding it: 1913: Pagenstecher noted the inheritance of “solutio retinae” in
hypermetropic children.25 X-linked retinoschisis1 can be called a retinovitreal dystrophy because retinal schisis, not vitreous syneresis, is the predominant sign. The common denominator of the retinal changes is thought to be Mueller cell degeneration,39 the sequelae of which are most visible in the fovea and in the periphery of the inferotemporal fundus.40 Peripheral changes only may be present in the rare autosomal dominant form.41 The wide range of biomicroscopic findings changes with the duration of the condition and age of the patient.1 The posterior vitreous adhesion (that is, premacular and prepapillary, as well as perivascular) is well developed in the young. Vitreous attachments to the inner layer of the schisis can cause progression of schisis through traction, particularly if vitreous contraction is accelerated by vitreous hemorrhage. Vitreous traction may lead to nasal dragging of the retina.42 The inner schisis layer consists of glia, nerve fiber layer, and vessels.40 Ultrastructural studies confirm the split along the ganglion cell and nerve fiber layer separating cell processes from their bodies in the inner nuclear layer and resulting in a picture of “decapitated and degenerated Mueller cells.”43 Whereas the inner layer of the schisis consists mostly of glial cells, the outer layer also provides a glial lining of the schisis cavity.43 Because vascularization of the inner retinal layers extends to the middle limiting membrane,44 schisis, however, takes place internal to the inner nuclear layer; the deep retinal capillaries may be disrupted, appearing angiographically as areas of nonperfusion.45 Inner layer atrophy may also ensue as a result of chronic inner layer ischemia and glial cell decapitation. Atrophic holes in the inner layer and perivascular gliosis may be the biomicroscopic corollaries. The outer layer may undergo atrophy or may be invaded by proliferations of the pigment epithelium.39,40 Retinal schisis involves a delicate balance between vitreous traction on the inner layer and the opposing strength of residual intraretinal bridges of tissue and adhesions of the outer layer of schisis to the pigment epithelium. Intraretinal strands of tissue that bridge the schisis cavity have been shown in vivo using the retinal thickness analyzer.46 If the vitreous gel is collapsed, the inner wall of the schisis is found in the retrolental space.33,40 Not surprisingly, such bullous schisis is more common in the young (i.e., in children younger than 10 years),47–49 often accompanied by vitreous and/or intraschisis hemorrhage.47 Visual loss in the young patient is often associated with contraction of adherent vitreous, bullous schisis, and its complications. It is a dynamic process; therefore, with increasing age bullous schisis tends to flatten spontaneously in the vast majority of cases.47,49 Application of a laser beam to the area of schisis has been shown to disrupt the equilibrium of vitreous traction and retinal adhesions and to produce rhegmatogenous detachments resulting from outer layer breaks as well as from full-thickness retinal breaks.50 Clinically, retinal schisis presents with decreased central visual acuity, absolute scotomas, or both.1,33,38 Children may have strabismus and nystagmus.25,47 As in FEVR, but in contrast to Wagner and Stickler syndrome, the refraction tends to be hypermetropic (“hypermetropic amblyopia”).1,25,26,31–34,40,48 On biomicroscopic examination, edema and cystic central macular schisis of the retina are apparent in virtually all cases.37,38 Loss of macular reflex, which may be an early sign,34,35 is followed by wheel-like formation,37 a multicystic radiate appearance (Fig. 1),38 pigmentary degeneration, and cystic macular atrophy (Fig. 2).38 These macular changes, not bullous schisis per se, determine visual loss in patients often in the fourth or fifth decade of life.51
Peripheral retinal schisis is present in half of the patients and in 96% is located in the inferotemporal quadrant.48 At least initially, the inner layer of the schisis is attached to the vitreous and features vessels, internal limiting membrane, and nerve fiber layer. These tissues undergo progressive atrophy as well as reactive gliosis, which in a perivascular location may appear as vascular sheathing (Fig. 3). Total atrophy may result in dehiscences and peripheral arborization of the retinal vasculature.33,34,45 Optic atrophy may follow.40 The outer layer of the schisis cavity also undergoes atrophy, reactive gliosis, intralayer pigment migration, and hole formation. A rhegmatogenous detachment may be the sequela in 4% to 22% of all patients.30,42,49,51–53 With time, the vitreous undergoes syneresis and detachment.31,33,40 Vitreous detachment actually may improve the schisis by releasing traction. Adhesions to retinal vessels are responsible for frequently found vitreous hemorrhages.29,31,40 Because progression of the disease cannot be predicted and regression sometimes occurs, patients should be observed regularly, particularly those younger than 10 years of age.47 Indications for surgical intervention are rhegmatogenous retinal detachment and repeated vitreous hemorrhages. Photocoagulation has not been shown to be beneficial in that it creates external wall holes.50 Such prophylactic treatment has led to retinal detachment in 14% to 43% of cases.48,49 This failure may be related to the fact that most of the mechanical cohesiveness of the retina lies in the inner layer near its basement membrane. The usual energy levels for coagulation may be too intense for the thin outer layer. Similarly, scleral buckling has been shown to be marginally effective in treating the detachments. Redetachments after buckling were reported in up to 40%.48,53 In cases of vitreous hemorrhage and vitreous attachment to the inner layer of schisis, scleral buckling combined with pars plana vitrectomy techniques may be beneficial. Recent approaches to surgery have centered on removal of the inner layer of the schisis cavity,52,53 if possible by lens-sparing technique.54 The position of the inner layer is determined by vitreous forces in its degree of separation and topography (dragging). In many cases it may be impossible to separate the cortical vitreous from the inner layer of schisis. Inner layer retinectomy most definitely eliminates traction that might lead to redetachment and may account for the superior long-term results reported with this method.54 |
FAMILIAL EXUDATIVE VITREORETINOPATHY | ||
This entity, first described by Criswick and Schepens in 1969,2 is autosomal dominantly inherited,55 even though rare sporadic and X-linked recessive modes have been reported.56 Linkage analysis has located the gene for the autosomal dominant form
to the long arm of chromosome 11.17 FEVR can be found in patients of any age and is usually bilateral with
asymmetric expression.57 The refraction tends to be emmetropic or myopic and is not of much help
in distinguishing it from retinitis of prematurity (ROP).58 As in retinal schisis, the primary changes are in the retina, here characterized
by a nonperfused inner retinal layer. The vitreal changes are
secondary to chronic exudation into the vitreous, leading to contraction
and early posterior detachment of this passive extracellular tissue.59 Symptoms and clinical presentation are related to the extent of nonperfusion, which
in turn determines the degree of the ocular response. Three
stages are generally distinguished: the first stage of nonperfusion, the
second stage of localized tractional detachment, exudation, and
possibly neovascularization, and the third stage of tractional and exudative
retinal detachments.57,60 Neovascularization, if severe, portends a poor prognosis and appears much
like ROP, whereas subretinal exudation of lipid may be prominent enough
to suggest a diagnosis of Coats' disease. However, in FEVR, the
infrequent exudative detachment usually is combined with a tractional
fibrovascular preretinal membrane, whereas in Coats' disease abnormal
intraretinal vessels and compressed vitreous predominate. Not surprisingly, histologic
studies are concerned with the later stages of disease, showing
absence of intraretinal vessels57 and nonspecific fibrovascular preretinal membranes.61 For the early stages of FEVR, angiography shows V-shaped temporal retinal
nonperfusion posterior to the ora serrata (i.e., near the posterior vitreous base).60 The peripheral retinal vasculature features supernumerous vascular branchings, arteriovenous
shunt formation, and patterns of incomplete arteriovenous
interdigitation.62,63 The peripheral retinal vessels are hyperpermeable and leak underneath
the retina and into the vitreous base. Subretinal and peripheral retinal
fibrosis may also be noted.62 Vitreous collapse induces peripheral traction, retinal detachments, and
elevated neovascularization. The newly formed vessels tend to leak and
bleed, thus fueling a vicious circle of vitreous contraction and fibrosis. Further, nonperfusion corresponds to ischemia of the inner layer
of the retina and thus involves Mueller cells, the nuclei of which
are located in the inner nuclear layer. The combination of vitreous base
traction, Mueller cell ischemia, and response to exudation sets the
stage for retinal schisis, hole formation in the inner and outer layer
of the retina, granulomatous proliferations, and vitreous hemorrhage.62,63 Although a high incidence of vitreous detachment was described in early
publications, later writers have not found a high incidence.63 The vitreal changes of syneresis and synchysis, contraction, partial or
complete detachment, opacification, and traction-rhegmatogenous detachment
seem to be secondary to the retinal vasculopathy. The histologic
vascular changes are indistinguishable from those of ROP; however, FEVR
patients are not myopic and have no history of prematurity or neonatal
oxygen exposure.58,59 Mild forms of the disease that produce no symptoms predominate. They are characterized by areas of peripheral nonperfusion, cystoid degeneration, and condensation of the temporal vitreous base and vitreous membranes. Moderate forms of FEVR with visual blurring, floaters, or distortion involve vitreous base traction, flat or elevated neovascularization, and retinal or subretinal exudates. The severe forms of FEVR, which usually cause visual loss, are similar to cicatricial ROP, featuring macular heterotopia, falciform retinal folds, total retinal detachment, iris atrophy, neovascular glaucoma, and cataracts (Fig. 4).64,65 Therefore, angiography and a detailed family history are more important than vitreous findings in making the diagnosis of the uncomplicated early stages. These patients, if asymptomatic and without exudate, can be observed (Fig. 5). Treatments include cryotherapy or photocoagulation, directly applied to areas of nonperfusion, as well as vitrectomy and scleral buckling procedures.66 These interventions were often complicated by nonattachment and redetachment related to proliferative vitreoretinopathy. In one series, all operations performed on patients younger than 19 years of age were unsuccessful, in contrast to the successful reattachments in older patients.57 A more recent publication on the results of surgery in patients younger than 9 years of age reported anatomic reattachment in six of six and visual success in five of six patients.67 Reproliferation and amblyopia were the main problems, emphasizing the need for early surgery and aggressive patching therapy.
Without surgical intervention, the natural history of FEVR is one of progressive severe visual loss, often mitigated by asymmetry. FEVR is a lifelong disease. Early onset of symptoms portends a particularly poor visual prognosis, if associated with ocular findings of exudate or traction. Retinal detachment, macular dragging, and cataract are common late complications that can occur at any time, even after many years of apparent remission.57 |
DEGENERATIVE MYOPIA |
The inheritance of degenerative myopia is autosomal recessive,68 autosomal dominant,69 or X-linked recessive.70 If one accepts genetic transmission of degenerative myopia, then it may be a very common tapetoretinal dystrophy.71 Degenerative myopia may be apparent during the first decade of life, characterized by an increase in volume of the posterior segment. The sclera is stretched, resulting in thinning and scleral ectasia.72 In the choroid there are breaks in Bruch's membrane and thinning of both the choroid and the retinal pigment epithelium, as well as peripapillary staphylomas.73 Biomicroscopically, lacquer cracks and gyrate atrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium and choroid may be noted.74 The retina is also stretched, resulting in thinning and peripheral degeneration. In addition, the stretching of the vitreous gel leads to internal schisis of the vitreal collagenous matrix, syneresis, and synchysis.75 Degenerative myopia may be complicated by glaucoma, retinal detachment, and macular hemorrhage with or without choroidal neovascular membrane.76,77 Visual acuity, color vision, and electroretinography (ERG) may be subnormal, depending on the extent of degenerative changes. Myopia may be an isolated finding or part of the syndromes described in the following sections. |
WAGNER'S SYNDROME |
This autosomal dominant hyaloideoretinal degeneration is characterized
by vitreous liquefaction that corresponds to the optically empty vitreous
cavity seen biomicroscopically.4,8–12,78–82 The vitreous collagen is collapsed, resulting in threadlike avascular
membranes. There may be a peripheral ring-shaped vitreous detachment. Typically, the
vitreal veils run circumferentially. The membranes are
attached to the retina in areas of equatorial intraretinal pigmentation
often grouped around vessels.79,81 The pigment epithelium may atrophy and unmask the choroid. When this occurs, the
pigmented intervascular choroidal stroma becomes visible, appearing
as choroidal sclerosis or midperipheral tesselation. The walls
of the retinal vessels become sheathed and thickened or alternatively
become attenuated, particularly anterior to the equator. Perivascular
pigment migration may be present. Although all of these pathologic signs
are apparent on ophthalmoscopy, there is no universal agreement regarding
the definitive ones on which a diagnosis of Wagner's syndrome
can be based.8–12 According to most authors, the vitreous changes are the primary and principal
signs of this disease. Some authorities, however, distinguish
two types of Wagner's syndrome, one in which the vitreous findings
predominate and another in which the chorioretinal changes are dominant.9,80 Still others argue that Wagner's disease more likely represents what
has been described as Stickler's syndrome.12 In addition to the pathologic characteristics previously described, there
can be premature cataracts, white with pressure, lattice degeneration, meridional
folds, and optic atrophy. In another point of controversy, some
authors have included Robin's syndrome, genua valga and
cleft palate,80 chondrodysplasia, flat face, and other physiognomic alterations as signs
of Wagner's disease. Unlike patients with X-linked retinal schisis or FEVR, those with Wagner's or Stickler's disease tend to be myopic. Their color vision and dark adaptation are normal or only slightly subnormal. The ERG is moderately diminished and visual fields can be concentrically contracted.8,9,79,81 In contrast to Goldmann-Favre syndrome, there is no nyctalopia in Wagner's disease, which is seen relatively frequently in a referral retinal practice. The complication of retinal detachment is treated by scleral buckling and vitrectomy83; however, it should be remembered that in Wagner's original series, none of the patients had retinal detachment. |
GOLDMANN-FAVRE SYNDROME |
Unlike Wagner's syndrome, this hyaloideotapetoretinal degeneration is recessively inherited.84–86 As also occurs in X-linked retinoschisis, peripheral and foveal schisis may be present. Vision is initially normal but then deteriorates as macular schisis, edema, and/or atrophy develops. Angiographically, the involved retina shows leakage of dye or nonperfusion.87 The vitreous undergoes advanced liquefaction, as it does in Wagner's disease, and features preretinal membranes with holes. Goldmann-Favre syndrome also has similarities to retinitis pigmentosa. These include retinal pigmentation and chorioretinal atrophy, posterior subcapsular cataract, annular scotoma, and nyctalopia. On the ERG, the rod response is undetectable and the cone response to long-wavelength stimuli is reduced; this was formerly interpreted as “extinction” of the ERG.85,86,88 Employing more recent computer-averaged and spectral ERG technology, a large and abnormally negative response to short wavelengths and white light can be measured. This has been termed the enhanced S cone syndrome.89 Unlike in retinitis pigmentosa, the ERG can be largely stationary, which led to a first description of the syndrome.90 The similar ERG response suggests a similar gene defect for these entities with variable phenotypic expression: patients at the mild end of the spectrum have near-normal fundi and vision, but at the more severe end of the spectrum the disease combines variable elements of retinoschisis, Wagner's syndrome, retinitis pigmentosa, and the enhanced S cone syndrome.91 The spectral ERG is the most important diagnostic test, particularly in formes frustes of the phenotype.89,92,93 The findings are restricted to the eye. |
STICKLER'S SYNDROME |
Stickler's hereditary progressive ophthalmopathy is autosomal dominantly
inherited.94 Linkage studies have shown linkage of Stickler's disease and the
type 2 procollagen gene in some but not all families, suggesting genetic
heterogeneity.18–22 In contrast to retinoschisis, Wagner's syndrome, and Goldmann-Favre
syndrome, Stickler's syndrome has many nonocular manifestations, most
prominently orofacial and skeletal abnormalities. Abnormal collagen
fibrils might be the link between vitreous, retinal, and skeletal
changes. The ocular pathology resembles that of Wagner's syndrome, consisting
of myopia, vitreoretinal degeneration, perivascular pigmentary
retinopathy of both circumferential anterior and radial posterior
orientation, cataract, and retinal detachments.95 According to some authors, the circular epiretinal line of vitreous condensation
overlying the retinal midperiphery is thought to be pathognomonic
for Stickler's syndrome.96 The orofacial manifestations include flattening and hypoplasia of the
midface, high-arched palate, and palatoschisis, which may overlap with
Robin's syndrome, characterized by palatoschisis, glossoptosis, and
micrognathia.10 The most common skeletal findings include arthritis, arthropathy, spondyloepiphysial
dysplasia, kyphosis, pectus carinatum, genua valga, dysplastic
hips, and arachnodactyly. Sensorineural hearing loss or peripheral
neuropathy may also be present.96 It is apparent that the inheritance factor and the ocular effects of Wagner's syndrome and Stickler's syndrome may overlap.11,12 In fact, some patients initially diagnosed as having Wagner's have been reclassified as having Stickler's syndrome. Because of the genetic heterogeneity found with linkage analysis and the variable expression of these two syndromes, some members of the same family may have Wagner's, whereas others, in addition, have extraocular symptoms that are more consistent with Stickler's syndrome. Mutations in the procollagen gene limit its usefulness in establishing the diagnosis.21 Apart from variations in expressivity, age might be an important modifying factor.97 Posterior vitreous detachment has been implicated in causing rhegmatogenous detachments, and encircling buckles have been proposed as a preventive measure.98 Stickler's syndrome should be ruled out in all cases of Robin's syndrome, dominantly inherited myopia, deafness, cleft palate, and spondyloepiphysial dysplasia. |
ROBIN'S SYNDROME |
The constellation of clinical findings in Stickler's syndrome can overlap with the manifestations of Robin's syndrome.99,100 High myopia and the vitreal retinopathy of Wagner's or Stickler's syndrome may be found in combination with micrognathia, a high-arched palate, glossoptosis, and other skeletal abnormalities.5,11 Therefore, patients with micrognathia, cleft palate, and glossoptosis may have the ocular complications of Stickler's syndrome. However, because of the feeding problems related to the orofacial findings in Robin's syndrome, the diagnosis is obvious. The ocular signs are more subtle and need to be searched for. |
CLEFTING SYNDROMES |
The prominent association between palatoschisis and hereditary vitreoretinal degeneration was first noted in 1961.101 Clefting abnormalities may be part of both Robin's syndrome and Stickler's syndrome.5,11 Moreover, some definitions of Wagner's syndrome also include clefting abnormalities.9,11,81 Any child with the ocular signs of Stickler's syndrome should have an examination of the palate. The palate may be high-arched or there may be palatoschisis, which may be incomplete, ranging from submucous schisis or bifid uvula to rhinolalia aperta.102–104 Other oral facial abnormalities such as maxillary hypoplasia may be encountered. Patients may also have a flat and poorly developed nasal bridge, widely spaced eyes, and a receding chin.6 In a nonselected sample, 10.5% of children in a cleft palate clinic had findings consistent with Stickler's syndrome.99 Because the chance of inheriting Stickler's syndrome is 50%, making the diagnosis would be important for genetic counseling of the parents as well as close observation for symptoms of retinal detachment in affected children.99 |
SKELETAL DYSPLASIAS |
Vitreoretinal degeneration is associated with a wide variety of skeletal dysplasias, most prominently spondyloepiphysial dysplasias.7 These dysplasias are characterized by selective growth retardation; patients have short limbs, but their hands and feet are of normal size. The trunk may be abnormally short and there may be lumbar lordosis. The inheritance of these disorders, which also can include cleft palate and perceptive deafness, is autosomal dominant. |
CONCLUSION |
Retinal schisis, Goldmann-Favre syndrome, FEVR, and Wagner's syndrome are considered to be restricted to the eye. Subsequently, many clinical signs have been added to the definition of the latter syndrome. Moreover, confusion has arisen with respect to which features distinguish one syndrome with variable gene expression from one that is a genetically separate entity. Molecular genetics and linkage analysis will no doubt provide more answers in the future. Many of the diseases reviewed herein can be separated from one another on the basis of their inheritance pattern, refractive error, and clinical manifestations. For example, only retinoschisis is X-linked, whereas FEVR and Wagner's and Stickler's syndromes are autosomal dominant. GoldmannFavre syndrome is autosomal recessive; few cases have been reported. Therefore, except in cases of retinoschisis and Goldmann-Favre syndrome, it is most likely that one will find an autosomal dominant hyaloideoretinopathy. Retinoschisis and FEVR are associated with hyperopia, Wagner's and Stickler's syndromes with myopia. Vitreous hemorrhages are encountered most frequently in schisis and FEVR, whereas an empty vitreous is more frequently a result of Wagner's or Stickler's syndrome. More problematic in classification are the syndromes that include the ocular findings of Wagner's syndrome, most of which have autosomal dominant inheritance. From a nosologic point of view, it is tempting to subdivide the syndromes.11,12 However, from a clinical viewpoint it is important to realize that patients with congenital myopia, facial clefts, Robin's malformations, arthropathies, or skeletal abnormalities may have associated changes in the retina and vitreous that increase their risk of retinal detachment and blindness. In these patients, inspection and palpation of the palate should routinely follow scleral depression. How many distinct clinical syndromes are needed to distinguish the different aspects of vitreoretinal dystrophy is of less practical importance, given the fact that most of these distinctions are based on arbitrary definitions and speculations. In the absence of more definitive genetic information, the usefulness of vast amounts of descriptive detail must be judged by the reader. |